300th Whole Pie Eater’s Club Shirt Design Contest Info
Home of The
Whole Pie Eater Challenge
The rules are simple…finish an entire XXL Pie in one sitting (30 minutes or less) by yourself, and win a T-Shirt! We offer new designs regularly.
The Pies are 18 inches in diameter – making each slice almost a foot long!
* – Rules Updated As of 2/2/2023
XXL Pies Are
18 Inches in Diameter!
Fresh seafood served every day! From our famous Muscles Marinara to combination platters and many other seafood delights!
We have a wide selection of Italian dishes for you to choose from. We have many classic dishes and some originals too!
Our beer taps and wine selections are always rotating. We love to add local breweries and wineries on a regular basis.
What People are Saying
“Great Neighborhood Spot”
“What a great place. I came here for a quick bite and a beer and couldn’t have been more satisfied. The pizza was crisp and cheesy and the beer was cold and refreshing!! Service was prompt and friendly. A great neighborhood spot 🙂“
“Best Thin Style Pizza”
“The absolute “Best” thin style pizza anywhere and I’ve had pizza on 4 continents. Staff are friendly, courtious and caring. You have to try this place, you’ll become a “Regular” customer even if you try not to. “
“Pizza is Out of This World”
“Everyone needs to stop in here if you’re around the area. The drinks are tasty and the pizza is out of this world! Thin crust is their speciality and they got it locked down! It’s about 30 mins from home, but we’ll travel for good food!“
“Made My Birthday a Happy One”
“I decided I wanted to go here for my Birthday. Who doesn’t love a thin pie from this place! It definitely made my Birthday a happy one. Never have I been disappointed eating here. It is a drive but we will definitely come back soon.”
Here at Pete and Elda’s/Carmen’s Pizzeria, we have been serving our famous thin crust pizza for over 50 years in Neptune City, New Jersey. We have a full bar featuring old favorites and seasonal options. For drinks specials, visit us during happy hour or when we’re serving our Pima De Luna or Night Owl menus.
Pete and Elda’s is the perfect Italian restaurant for a family night out. We have been rated one of the best pizzerias on the Jersey Shore multiple times. In 2015, the Asbury Park Press readers named Pete and Elda’s their favorite slice. Eater New York has named us one of The Jersey Shore’s 25 Most Essential Restaurants.
Take out or dine in and get the whole family involved in our Whole Pie Eater’s club XXL pizza challenge!
96 Woodland Ave
Neptune City, NJ 07753
MON: 11AM - 11PM
TUE: 11AM - 11PM
WED: 11AM - 11PM
THU: 11AM - 11PM
FRI: 11AM - 1AM (Bar - 2AM)
SAT: 11AM - 1AM (Bar - 2AM)
SUN: 11AM - 11PM